It doesn't happen often that you get a DubListening to the album, one immediately realizes: A door is opening here that one didn't even know existed until just now.The Alien Dub Orchestra Plays the Breadminster Songbook“(Alien Transistor) is exactly that kind of moment. For me, it’s the strangest, most unusual, and probably most innovative.” Dub-publication of recent years – and an impressive testament to how far Dub This is possible if one frees oneself from traditions, production dogmas, and expectations.
The project itself is already extraordinary. The alien Dub Orchestra is a mixed group of Bavarian musicians – including some from the circles of The Notwist and G.Rag y los hermanos Patchekos. Their approach: the songs of British Dub-to record Elijah Minnelli's eccentric songs from his so-called Breadminster Songbook with a full band. Minnelli, who otherwise – by his own account – assembles his "frayed, melancholic hymns to his homeland" on his computer in a damp basement, was himself taken aback by the idea. "Real professionals playing something you've pieced together yourself – it's overwhelming," he says. And indeed: His quirky music suddenly sounds as he perhaps always intended it to.
The album works its way through Minnelli's cumbia-infused DubReggae – but instead of digital loops and a rough-mix atmosphere, there's a fully instrumented, almost anarchically colorful band lineup: guiro, accordion, melodica, sousaphone, trumpet, and all sorts of percussion. It sounds as if a Munich backyard collective rediscovered old Studio One recordings, European folk tradition, and South American rhythms simultaneously and simply mashed them together. Weird? Yes. But above all, mind-blowing.
Tracks like "Vine and Fig Tree" demonstrate what happens when you suddenly shape Minnelli's enigmatically beautiful melodies from wood and metal instead of bits and bytes: The harmonies become tangible, the bass (this time as a wailing sousaphone line!) gains that physical warmth that only real air columns and real hands can produce. With other tracks—such as "Slats"—you almost wonder if Minnelli's original wasn't subconsciously intended for this band. It sounds so natural, so unique, so complete.
And then comes the second part of the album – the real mindfuck: the Dub-Versions! A circular metamorphosis that finally places the project in the experimental realm beyond... Dub-conventions catapulted. For these DubMinnelli brought in sound artist Raimund Wong, who works with an anarchic setup of tape machines and effects chains. Everything was mixed in one take: Minnelli on the faders, Wong with filters and effects that Dub break down, distort, liquefy.
"Pundit Dub“ is perhaps the best example – a hypnotic, droning trip that dissolves into psychedelic wisps and sounds as if the entire album is gliding through a portal into another dimension. It's not a classic Dub and nobody wants to be one. It is Dub as an idea, as a collapse, as a radical opening of form.
Ultimately, "Play the Breadminster Songbook" is nothing less than a love letter to Dub as a living principle. Folk, Cumbia, DubAvant-garde – everything collides, overlaps, and merges without ever becoming arbitrary. The music feels like a constant transformation, an open dialogue between Minnelli's digital intimacy and the analog exuberance of a band that clearly revels in disregarding the rules.
I would conclude: This album shows how far Dub Since King Tubby arrived – and that it's still possible to stretch and bend him, yet still let his core shine through. "Play the Breadminster Songbook" is quirky, bold, playful, and visionary. For me, the most innovative DubA project of recent years. A masterpiece of the unconventional.

6 replies to “The Alien Dub Orchestra: Play the Breadminster Songbook”
I can only agree with you, dear René!
That's true for me too. Dub Album of the year! I even dedicated a short radio show to it back then. You can listen to it here: https://www.nrwision.de/mediathek/jamaican-flavours-the-alien-dub-orchestra-plays-the-breadminster-songbook-250923/
Greetings, eekakraus
Oh yes, the playlist: https://www.jamaicanflavours.de/jamaican-flavours-19-09-25-playlist/
Yes! Let's break the rules! It's always fun! Provided it doesn't hurt anyone.
This is another real snack for DubConnoisseurs.
To the whole DubTo truly appreciate art, I always have to have everything ready with albums like this so I'm not distracted by unnecessary movements or even superfluous trips. So I would never put this album on if I were tidying up in the kitchen or anywhere else. When this kind of music is playing, I need to be fully focused. Although I'm not exactly known for being able to concentrate in any way. But with this music, it happens all by itself, or rather, automatically. I've already listened to Minnelli's album and thought, "Nicely quirky," but somehow also too harsh, or perhaps a bit too electronic. Being electronic isn't really a deal-breaker, but if it sounds too much like, say, keyboard bass, and the effects don't really "swing," then it's not so important anymore.
I also have to somehow connect this album to the On.U Sound cosmos. However, with Adrian Sherwood's "Collapse Of Everything," this experimental music certainly doesn't exist as the only "quirky, bold, playful, and visionary" variant of the global sound. DubMusic. For example, Jeff The Brotherhood with Blanc du Blanc immediately comes to mind. Also "quirky, bold, visionary, and playful." There's hardly an album where I don't want to skip over one or two tracks, or sometimes even have to. And that's the case here again. I don't necessarily have to skip "Vine and Fig Tree," but I don't absolutely need to listen to it again either. The vocals and groove just don't grab me. "Bike Black" isn't really my thing either. "Kissing Circles" grabs me with its percussion and driving bassline. "Pruning Hooks"! The accordion here makes me very happy, and the percussion(s) are particularly effective in the second half. DubThe tunes, together with the deep, bubbling bassline, almost form an instrumental reasoning from the entire tune.
The vocals aren't strictly necessary here either, but they don't really bother me. Perhaps they'll even improve after several listens. "Caprinae Subfamily" captivates me in a similar way. I won't write any more about it now, because I finally want to express my enthusiasm for "Pundit". Dub“Get rid of it. Bassline, percussion, accordion, and hypnotic special effects really send me on a kind of trip into “foreign” dimensions. Although I have to say that these dimensions are unfamiliar to most people.” DubThis will probably be familiar to connoisseurs. Because in principle, that's – at least for me – the reason why I always enjoy it so much. DubI listen to music. "Slats" is also one of my top favorites on this album. Actually for the same reason as "Pundit". Dub".
Well, these DubThese are really unusual, and if I didn't like them so much, I'd say I'm missing some proper drums, and especially that snare drum hit, which is so characteristic. DubAddicts are practically forced to use a lot of reverb and adorn themselves with a deep echo. Yes, the drums are there, but they're played in a rather "jazzy, cool" way, if I'm not mistaken. But even though I'm using the word "jazz" here, it's not meant to be a bad thing. While "jazz" can often really get on my nerves, that doesn't make it a dirty word for me.
“Who let the jazz out?” ………………….. lemmi
"This is another real snack for..." DubConnoisseurs.” ——— ääääääähm — no!
It is wonderful to see innovations with Dub music in 2025. This album from Alien Dub Orchestra is a great example.