Categories
Five Star Review

The Skatalites: Herb Dub – Collie Dub

Although the Original Skatalites with trombonist Don Drummond only existed from May 1964 to August 1965, they occupy an almost mystical place in Jamaica's diverse musical history.
Ten years after the death of Don Drummond and the sad end of the Skatalites, bassist Lloyd Brevett brought together some of his former bandmates for a reunion. The sessions were produced by Lloyd Brevett and Glen Darby, who sang for Coxsone Dodd at Studio One at the age of 14 and was a member of the Scorchers. The core line-up for this project was the hard core of the legendary Skatalites: Lloyd Brevett, Lester Sterling, Rolando Alphonso, Tommy McCook and Jackie Mittoo. But that wasn't all, the best studio musicians of the time such as Horsemouth Wallace, Benbow Creary, Augustus Pablo, Chinna Smith, Ernest Ranglin were also on board, and Don Drummond's trombone was replaced by Vin Gordon. But the biggest coup, in my opinion, was the addition of the Sons Of Negus Nyahbinghi Dummer Bongo T, I-Marts and Sidney Wolf. Lloyd Brevett wanted a sound like the one he had experienced as a teenager at the grounations in the Rasta camps of Wareika Hills and Bull Bay, because these chanting and reasoning sessions had a lasting impact on him both musically and mentally.
Lloyd developed the melodies and rhythms for the upcoming studio sessions together with Tommy McCook during a number of jam sessions at his house in Henderson Avenue, Waltham Park Road. The Nyahbinghi drummers are said to have already taken part in the sessions.
After that, they went to Black Ark Studio, where three tracks from the album were recorded. Brevett recalls that he, McCook and the Nyahbinghi drummers were accompanied by Benbow Creary, Augustus Pablo and Chinna Smith. The remaining five tracks on the album were recorded at Aquarius Studio by Herman Chin Loy. At Aquarius, the list of musicians was expanded to include Rolando Alphonso, Lester Sterling and Johnny Moore. Ernest Ranglin replaced Chinna Smith, and Benbow was replaced by Leroy "Horsemouth" Wallace. The album was released in 1976 under the title "The legendary Skatalites". Later editions were simply called "African Roots". Some time later, the Dubversion of the album under the title “The Skatalites: Herb Dub – Collie Dub“ in a mini edition of 200 copies. The tapes produced at the Black Ark were taken to King Tubby in Dromilly Avenue, Kingston 11, who made three fantastic Dubs. For the instrumental tracks recorded at Aquarius Studio, Lloyd Brevett suggested that the Dubs directly mixed by Herman Chin Loy. But Clive Hunt insisted that the mixing be split between him and Karl Pitterson. Although the album was recorded in two completely different studios, the sound is homogeneous, complex, profound and of the highest musical quality. Glen Darby remembers that for the musicians involved in this album it was always more than just another recording session. "They didn't really do it for the money. They wanted to revive the band, the Skatalites." It became a reunion album, because three years later the Skatalites were on tour again. In any case, the Skatalites' recordings never sounded like they did on this album before or after. This is not ska, this is real Nyahbinghi roots reggae Dub of rare quality, wonderfully played and mixed. An essential album that is finally being re-released on vinyl by LB Records/Studio 16 and definitely belongs in every collection.

Rating: 5 out of 5.

FYI: Since I couldn't find the 2024 re-release on any streaming platform, I unfortunately had to resort to the compilation of the 2001 release, but in my opinion that's not a big deal, because it offers a lot more.

9 Responses to “The Skatalites: Herb Dub – Collie Dub"

For further information you can find the correct titles plus the order of the instrumental and Dub-Version:

Bottom Dub is a dub of 'Rock Bottom'
whispering Dub is a dub of 'Candle Light'
Dumboo Dub is a dub of 'Jumbo Malt'
Kimble Dub is a dub of 'Fugitive'*
Herb Dub-Collie Dub is a dub of 'Herb Challice'
sealing Dub is a dub of 'Seven Seal'*
African Dub is a dub of 'African Roots' *
Roots Dub is a dub of ‚Stream In The Meadow

* recorded at Lee Perry's Black Ark & mixed at King Tubby's!

Reply

First of all, a healthy new year to everyone here.
I bought the LP affordably from Juno Records in the UK. With taxes and postage included, it was still quite reasonable.
Question: I really don't have a connection to mailorder here in Germany. Is there anything I can recommend? I always look at JVC or hhv, but I would like to buy from the base. Buyreggae.com here in Berlin is there when it comes to Dub only semi-suitable for my needs.
Please let us know, where do you buy or order?
Dankeschön!

Hi Andi, I wish you and all other readers a happy and, above all, healthy 2025!

At the moment, the only one that comes to mind is Irie Records in Münster (irie-records.de). Whether you can find the Herb Dub – Collie Dub I can't tell you at the moment what you would have received.

Yo! Happy New Year everyone!

You won't always find the vinyl or other shiny plastic you're looking for for every album. But irie records is (not just for me) something like the basis for reggae music. I think I know that in the 70s and 80s, without irie records, things would have been pretty bad for vinyl reggae freaks. From 7" to 10" and all the maxi versions, you could get almost everything that was produced in Jamaica and England. LPs of course! It may be that the online shop operators (which is now irie records too) were and are also fully committed to it, but irie records is something very special and I would say that you could easily make two films about the owner that wouldn't be boring at any point. Provided there was always a camera there. So you would probably have to make do with an audio book, or if you like it, you would definitely enjoy reading a book about it.
Anyway, I don't know if my link will work properly here, but the vinyl album is listed at irie records for a very reasonable price.
http://www.irie-records.com/
But maybe I am too late with my information again ………

Greetings………lemmi

Yes, that's a shame. I wanted to come across as cool and link to the album, but my link only takes you to the homepage of irie records. But just a few clicks of the mouse and you'll find it, of course, at Skatalites.

So long …………… .. lemmi

Leave a Comment

Your e-mail address will not be published. Required fields are marked with * marked

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed..